NEITHER DOES WILSON.
Dude, I don't know how you can even sit there and argue that the Seahawks have anywhere near the most talented team in the league. They've have a talented defense, but that's completely irrelevant as far as the QB goes. And man, playing head to head one time and winning one time doesn't suddenly mean he's the better QB. The Seahawks have an AWFUL offensive line. Their playing 7th round picks and UDFA's at three of the five slots, they've lost both their starting LT and back-up LT (though even Okung isn't all that good pass blocking) their guard play is abysmal, they've got basically nothing but a decent RG and RT, but even they suck quite a bit of the time. The only reason Wilson doesn't get sacked as much as Luck does is because Wilson is naturally gifted at eluding and evading. He's so shifty and quick that it's hard to sack him. Russell Wilson is the most PRESSURED QB in the NFL, at 39%. 39% of his snaps, there is someone in his face. 39%. That's not one game, or one month, that's his entire year. I don't care who you are, being pressured nearly 40% of the time in absurd.
Russell Wilson- 100.7 passer rating
Andrew Luck- 80.1 passer rating
Russell Wilson- 43 TDs
Andrew Luck- 37 TDs
Russell Wilson- 16 INTs
Andrew Luck- 24 INTs
Russell Wilson- 63.8 completion percentage
Andrew Luck- 55.7 completion percentage
Russell Wilson- 8.1 yards per attempt
Andrew Luck- 7.0 yards per attempt
Russell Wilson- 12.7 yards per completion
Andrew Luck- 12.6 yards per completion
Russell Wilson- 6.6 touchdown percentage
Andrew Luck- 3.9 touchdown percentage
Russell Wilson- 2.5 interception percentage
Andrew Luck- 2.6 interception percentage
Russell Wilson has better numbers, Russell Wilson has better efficiency, Russell Wilson has more TD's and less INT's. The only thing he doesn't have is bulk yardage stats but those are completely irrelevant. Just because they played ONE TIME and the COLTS, beat the SEAHAWKS, doesn't mean LUCK beat WILSON. It's not hard to understand. I mean how can you even say Luck proved to be better after that game after Wilson went pound for pound with him?
Other than Lynch, who on that Seahawks offense would you take on the Colts that would start? Golden Tate, maybe? Jermaine Kearse? Doug Baldwin?
Frontrunner for MVP is so asinine. You're SUCH a homer it's freaking astounding. No, no he wouldn't be. The best offensive player on a team that, right now, is 9-0, would be. Then after him it'd be the guy who's ALSO playing quite well in Drew Brees, then probably Calvin Johnson or Matt Stafford.
Again. Come from behind wins are completely irrelevant as far as QB play. And no, I'm sorry, but Mediocre teams don't go 6-3, good teams do. That's what the Colts are. Their a good team. But they aren't a great team, they haven't bean a great team all day.
I'm not hating on Andrew Luck. Jesus mean I said point blank he's a good young QB that has some glaring flaws that aren't accounted for because of his O-line. He has these flaws even when he has time. He has a tendency to throw off his back foot even without pressure, his accuracy is streaky, he makes a lot of boneheaded mistakes and his arm limits what he can do. But he's got good mechanics on the run, he's mechanically very sound in the pocket when he sets his feet right, he's got good mobility. But he needs to put things together. He makes way too many bonehead throws right now to be considered a top tier/top 10 QB, let alone MVP.